1999 Pokemon 1st Edition Machamp Holo (Error) Value & Price Guide

Here's a fact that confuses almost every Pokemon card collector at some point: every Base Set Machamp holo has a 1st Edition stamp on it. Every single one. The "unlimited" print runs, the later shadow border versions, even the ones that came in starter decks sold at Target in 2000. They all say 1st Edition.

That means having a 1st Edition Machamp does not mean you have a rare card. What matters is which 1st Edition Machamp you have. And that distinction is worth understanding, because it's the difference between a $10 card and a $5,000 card.

Quick Value Summary

Item: Machamp Holo #8/102 (Base Set, 1st Edition) Year: 1999-2000 Set: Pokemon Base Set Category: Trading Cards (Pokemon TCG)

Condition Range:

• Shadowless 1st Edition, PSA 7 (Near Mint): $100 - $250

• Shadowless 1st Edition, PSA 8 (Near Mint-Mint): $200 - $400

• Shadowless 1st Edition, PSA 9 (Mint): $400 - $1,000

• Shadowless 1st Edition, PSA 10 (Gem Mint): $2,000 - $5,000

• Shadowed 1st Edition, PSA 10: $50 - $150

• Base Set 2000 (Shadowed, 1st Ed), PSA 10: $30 - $80

Record Sale: Approximately $5,040 (shadowless 1st Edition, PSA 10, Fanatics Collect listing) Rarity: Shadowless version: Uncommon. Shadowed version: Common.

The Story

When Wizards of the Coast brought the Pokemon Trading Card Game to North America in January 1999, Machamp was included in the 2-Player Starter Set as a guaranteed holo card. Every starter set had one. This was different from the booster pack holos (Charizard, Blastoise, Venusaur, etc.), which were pulled randomly.

Because Machamp was a guaranteed inclusion in the starter set, Wizards printed it with a 1st Edition stamp from the very first run and simply... never removed it. When they transitioned from 1st Edition to Unlimited printing for the regular Base Set, they updated the booster pack cards to remove the 1st Edition stamp. But the starter set Machamp kept its stamp through every print run. This wasn't an error in the traditional sense. It was a production decision that was never corrected.

The result is a card that looks special (1st Edition! Holo!) but is actually one of the most common holos in the entire Base Set. Millions of starter sets were sold. Every one had a Machamp.

The exception is the shadowless version. The very first print runs of the Base Set used a shadowless card design, meaning the art box on the right side of the card has no drop shadow behind it. The shadowless 1st Edition Machamp came from the earliest starter sets, produced alongside the first and second print runs of Base Set boosters. These are genuinely scarce and represent the true "first edition" of the card.

How to Identify It

Shadowless vs. Shadowed (the key distinction):

Shadowless (valuable):

• No shadow effect on the right side of the illustration box

• The border area to the right of the art appears uniformly colored

• 1st Edition stamp in the lower left of the art box

• Copyright line reads "\u00a9 1995, 96, 98, 99 Nintendo" (no 2000)

Shadowed (common):

• A visible drop shadow on the right and bottom edges of the illustration box

• 1st Edition stamp still present (this is the confusing part)

• Copyright may read "\u00a9 1995, 96, 98, 99 Nintendo" or include "2000"

Base Set 1999-2000 version:

• Shadowed border

• 1st Edition stamp present

• Copyright includes the year 2000

• The least valuable variant

Galaxy/Cosmos foil variant:

• Different holofoil pattern (galaxy swirl rather than standard holo)

• From the CD promo set

• PSA 10: approximately $1,100

Quick check: Look at the right edge of the card art box. If there's a shadow, it's the common version. No shadow = shadowless = the valuable one.

Value by Condition

Shadowless 1st Edition:

PSA 5-6 (Excellent to Excellent-Mint): $30 - $80 Noticeable wear, possible whitening on edges. Still identifiable as shadowless. At this grade, you're collecting for the variant, not the condition.

PSA 7 (Near Mint): $100 - $250 Minor edge wear, decent centering. The card presents well but has small imperfections under magnification.

PSA 8 (Near Mint-Mint): $200 - $400 Sharp corners, good centering, minimal surface issues. This is where the card starts to feel like a real collectible.

PSA 9 (Mint): $400 - $1,000 Nearly perfect. Slight centering variance or a minor surface imperfection keeps it from a 10. The PSA population at this grade is moderate.

PSA 10 (Gem Mint): $2,000 - $5,000 Perfect centering, flawless surfaces, sharp corners. These are scarce because the cards came in starter decks, not individual packaging, so handling damage is common. The PSA 10 population is relatively small compared to other Base Set holos.

Shadowed 1st Edition:

PSA 10: $50 - $150 This is the version most people have. Even in perfect condition, the enormous supply keeps prices modest. Below PSA 10, expect $5 - $30.

Price trend: Shadowless versions have appreciated steadily as collectors have become more educated about the difference. Shadowed versions have been flat, held back by oversupply.

Known Errors and Variations

The 1st Edition "error" itself: The persistent 1st Edition stamp across all print runs is the defining characteristic of this card. Some collectors and grading references label the shadowed version an "error" because it carries a 1st Edition stamp despite being from a later, unlimited-equivalent print run.

Cosmos/Galaxy foil: A version from the Pokemon CD promo set features a different holofoil pattern. This is a separate product, not a Base Set variant.

Trainer Deck A non-holo: An extremely rare non-holographic version from the Trainer Deck A demonstration set. These are genuinely scarce but serve a niche collector audience.

Authentication & Fakes

Fake Pokemon cards are widespread, but Machamp fakes are less common than Charizard fakes simply because the card is less valuable. Still:

• Feel the card stock: Genuine cards have a specific weight and stiffness. Fakes often feel too thin or too glossy.

• Check the holofoil: Authentic Base Set holos have a specific star pattern to their foil. Fakes may have foil that's too reflective or has the wrong pattern.

• Light test: Holding a genuine card up to a bright light reveals a specific opacity. Many fakes are too transparent or too opaque.

PSA grading is recommended for shadowless copies you plan to sell. At $25-50 for economy grading, it's a worthwhile investment for a card that can be worth $500+ in PSA 9. For shadowed versions, grading is only worth it if the card is in pristine condition.

Where to Sell

Best venues:

• eBay: The largest market for Pokemon cards. Hundreds of Machamp sales monthly. Fees ~13%.

• TCGPlayer: Popular specifically for trading cards. Lower fees than eBay for some categories.

• PWCC/Goldin: For high-grade shadowless examples (PSA 9-10).

• Local card shops: May buy ungraded copies but at 40-60% of market value.

Expected selling costs:

• PSA grading: $25 - $75 depending on turnaround

• eBay fees: ~13%

• Shipping: $5 - $15

Not sure which version you have? Upload a photo to Curio Comp and we'll help identify shadowless vs. shadowed.

Related Items