1938 US Presidential $5 Calvin Coolidge (Scott #834 Coil Pair)

The $5 Calvin Coolidge stamp from the 1938 Presidential Issue series holds a unique position in American philately. As the highest denomination in one of the most beloved definitive stamp series ever produced, Scott #834 represents both a practical piece of postal history and a genuine collector's prize. When found as a coil pair, this stamp becomes something even more interesting: a format that was produced in limited quantities and that relatively few collectors think to pursue. Let's take a close look at what makes this stamp special and what collectors should know about its value.

The 1938 Presidential Issue Series

The 1938 Presidential Issue, affectionately known as the "Prexies" among stamp collectors, is one of the most significant definitive stamp series in United States postal history. Issued between 1938 and 1954, the series featured portraits of all deceased U.S. presidents as of 1938, arranged in chronological order from George Washington (half-cent) through Calvin Coolidge ($5).

The series was designed by Elaine Rawlinson and engraved by some of the Bureau of Engraving and Printing's finest craftsmen. The design approach was elegant in its simplicity: each stamp featured an oval portrait of the president, his name below, and the denomination, all set within a clean border. The color of each stamp was unique to its denomination, making the series visually distinctive and easy to sort.

The Prexie series encompassed 32 denominations ranging from the half-cent Benjamin Franklin to the $5 Calvin Coolidge. The series proved enormously popular with both postal users and collectors, and its long production run (spanning the war years and into the early 1950s) created a rich variety of printings, perforation types, and usage combinations that sustain collector interest to this day.

Calvin Coolidge on the $5 Stamp

Calvin Coolidge was chosen for the $5 denomination because he was the most recently deceased president at the time the series was designed. Coolidge, the 30th President of the United States, served from 1923 to 1929 and died in 1933. Known as "Silent Cal" for his famously laconic personality, Coolidge presided over the prosperous 1920s and left office before the Great Depression began.

The $5 Coolidge stamp (Scott #834) was first issued on November 17, 1938. It was printed in carmine and black, using a bi-color printing process that set it apart from the lower denominations (which were printed in single colors). The $2 Warren G. Harding (Scott #833) also received the bi-color treatment, making the two highest values in the series visually distinctive.

This was the first time Calvin Coolidge appeared on a United States postage stamp, adding another layer of historical significance to the issue. The portrait used was based on a formal presidential photograph, capturing Coolidge's characteristically serious expression.

Understanding Coil Pairs

The "coil pair" format is where this collectible gets particularly interesting. Most Prexie stamps were issued as sheet stamps, printed in large flat sheets and then separated into individual stamps or panes. However, several denominations were also produced as coil stamps, printed in continuous rolls for use in vending machines and affixing machines.

A coil pair consists of two attached coil stamps, which collectors value because the pair format provides proof that the stamps originated from a coil roll rather than being individual sheet stamps with trimmed perforations. Coil stamps have perforations on two sides (top and bottom for vertical coils, left and right for horizontal coils) and straight edges on the other two sides.

For the high-value $5 denomination, coil production was significantly more limited than sheet production. The $5 stamp saw relatively little everyday postal use (it would have covered substantial postage in an era when a standard letter cost just three cents), and coil format production reflected that limited demand.

Condition and Value Guide

The value of a Scott #834 $5 Calvin Coolidge stamp varies significantly based on format, condition, and usage. Here is a comprehensive pricing guide:

Format/Condition	Description	Price Range
Used Single	Cancelled, good condition	$2 - $5
Mint Single (NH)	Never hinged, fresh	$40 - $75
Mint Single (Superb, NH)	Perfectly centered, never hinged	$150 - $300
Mint Plate Block	Block of 4 with plate number, NH	$200 - $350
Coil Pair (Mint, NH)	Two attached coil stamps, never hinged	$250 - $500
Coil Pair (Used)	Two attached coil stamps, cancelled	$50 - $100
Coil Line Pair (Mint, NH)	Pair with printed guide line, never hinged	$400 - $800
On Cover (Solo Use)	Single stamp on correctly rated cover	$100 - $500+
On Cover (Coil, Solo)	Coil stamp on correctly rated cover	$500 - $1,500+

Several factors can push values higher:

Centering: Stamps that are perfectly centered within their perforations (graded as "Superb" or receiving high numerical grades from PSE or other grading services) command substantial premiums. A perfectly centered mint copy of Scott #834 is genuinely difficult to find.

Freshness: Stamps with bright, unfaded colors and clean gum (for mint examples) are preferred. Tropical staining, gum disturbances, and color changes from light exposure all reduce value.

Usage: Stamps on cover (still attached to the envelope or package they franked) are often worth more than off-cover stamps, particularly when the usage is correct for the rate. A $5 Coolidge paying a specific postal rate on a properly dated cover tells a story that a mint stamp alone cannot.

The Prexie Coil Challenge

Collecting Prexie coils is a specialty within a specialty. Not all Prexie denominations were issued in coil format, and for those that were, the coils can be challenging to find, particularly in pairs and line pairs.

The $5 denomination coil is among the scarcer Prexie coils. While exact production figures for coil rolls are not always available, the $5 value would have been produced in far smaller quantities than common denominations like the 1-cent or 3-cent coils. This limited production, combined with the fact that most coil stamps were fed through machines (which could damage them), means that clean, well-centered coil pairs are surprisingly hard to find.

Line pairs (coil pairs that include a printed guide line between the two stamps) are even scarcer and more valuable. The guide line was used in production to help align the printing and cutting equipment, and its presence on a coil pair is considered a premium feature by collectors.

Authentication and Expertization

For high-value Prexie stamps, particularly coil formats of the $5 denomination, expert authentication is recommended. The primary concern is distinguishing genuine coil stamps from sheet stamps that have been fraudulently trimmed to simulate straight coil edges.

Expertization by organizations such as the Philatelic Foundation or the American Philatelic Expertizing Service can confirm that a coil stamp is genuine. These services examine the stamp under magnification, compare it to known genuine examples, and issue certificates of authenticity.

For coil pairs valued in the hundreds of dollars, the cost of expertization (typically $25 to $50 per item) is a worthwhile investment in confidence and marketability.

Collecting Strategies

There are several rewarding ways to incorporate the $5 Coolidge into a stamp collection:

Complete Prexie Set: Assembling one example of each denomination in the Presidential Issue series. The $5 is the capstone of this set and the most valuable single stamp in the series.

Prexie Coil Specialist: Focusing exclusively on coil versions of each Prexie denomination. This approach yields a compact but challenging collection that tests both your sourcing skills and your knowledge of coil identification.

Rate Usage Collection: Assembling covers showing the $5 Coolidge paying specific postal rates. This approach combines philately with postal history and can be endlessly fascinating.

Denomination Focus: Collecting the $5 Coolidge across all formats: sheet single, plate block, coil single, coil pair, coil line pair, and various on-cover usages.

Historical Significance

The 1938 Presidential Issue series reflects a particular moment in American history. Issued on the eve of World War II, the Prexies would serve as the nation's primary definitive stamps through the war years and into the early Cold War period. Letters sent by soldiers, government correspondence, and everyday mail all carried these stamps, making them ubiquitous artifacts of mid-century American life.

The $5 denomination was used for heavy parcels, registered mail, and international packages. Finding a genuine wartime use of the $5 Coolidge on cover is a thrilling discovery for postal historians. These covers document the movement of goods and correspondence during one of the most significant periods in world history.

Calvin Coolidge himself, though often overshadowed by the dramatic presidencies that preceded and followed his own, has experienced a reassessment in recent decades. His commitment to limited government and fiscal restraint resonates with modern audiences, and his placement on the highest value stamp in this celebrated series ensures that his image remains a part of the philatelic conversation.

The $5 Calvin Coolidge stamp, whether as a simple mint single or as a scarce coil pair, offers collectors a fascinating intersection of presidential history, postal history, and the craft of stamp production. It is the kind of collectible that rewards close study and patient acquisition, and it serves as a fitting capstone to one of the finest stamp series ever produced.

Browse all Stamps →

Related Items