Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1 (1984 Mirage) Value & Price Guide

Two guys in their twenties pooled their tax refunds, borrowed from a relative, and printed 3,000 copies of a black-and-white comic about four mutated turtles who knew ninjutsu. Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird called their publishing company Mirage Studios, which was a joke. There was no studio. They worked out of Eastman's living room in Dover, New Hampshire. The print run cost them about $1,200.

Forty years later, a single copy of that comic in CGC 9.8 sold for $245,000.

Quick Value Summary

Item: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1 (First Printing) Year: 1984 Publisher: Mirage Studios Category: Comic Books

Condition Range (First Printing):

• Good (2.0-3.0): $750 - $2,000

• Fine (5.0-6.0): $3,000 - $7,000

• Very Fine (7.0-8.0): $8,000 - $25,000

• Near Mint (9.0-9.4): $30,000 - $75,000

• Near Mint/Mint (9.6-9.8): $100,000 - $245,000

Record Sale: $245,000 (CGC 9.8, ComicConnect, September 2021) Rarity: Very Rare (approximately 3,000 first printing copies, plus roughly 200 extra to cover printing spoilage)

The Story

The origin of TMNT reads like the kind of story that shouldn't work. In late 1983, Eastman drew a sketch of a turtle standing upright with nunchucks strapped to its arms. He showed it to Laird. They laughed. Then they started riffing on it. What if there were four turtles? What if they were named after Renaissance artists? What if they were trained by a rat?

The comic was a parody. Specifically, it was a parody of everything popular in comics at the time: Frank Miller's Daredevil run (the Hand became the Foot Clan, Stick became Splinter), the New Mutants, Ronin, and Cerebus. The name itself was designed to be absurd. Teenage. Mutant. Ninja. Turtles. Four adjectives that had no business being in the same sentence.

Eastman and Laird advertised in the Comics Buyer's Guide and took pre-orders. The first printing of 3,000 copies (plus roughly 200 extra for spoilage) shipped in May 1984. It sold out almost immediately. A second printing of 15,000 followed, then a third of 35,000. By the late 1980s, the turtles had a cartoon show, a toy line, and a movie franchise. The self-published black-and-white parody had become a billion-dollar property.

The first printing is identifiable by the absence of any printing notation on the inside front cover. Second and third printings are clearly marked. First printings also tend to have slightly rougher print quality, which is typical of small-run offset printing from that era.

How to Identify It

Key visual markers:

• Black-and-white interior pages throughout (no color)

• Cover shows all four turtles in action poses against a dark background, with Splinter visible in a circular inset at the top

• "Eastman and Laird's" appears above the title on the cover

• Cover price: $1.50

• First printing: No printing number or edition notation on the inside front cover or indicia

Printing identification:

• First printing (3,000 copies): No print notation. Most valuable.

• Second printing (15,000 copies): Marked "Second Printing" on the inside front cover. Values roughly 10-15% of the first printing.

• Third printing (35,000 copies): Marked "Third Printing." Values roughly 5-8% of the first printing.

• Fourth and fifth printings: Progressively lower values. Later printings added color covers.

• Counterfeit alert: Fakes exist that attempt to remove or alter printing notations on later printings. Paper quality, ink density, and binding are tell-tale differences.

Common confusions:

• Don't confuse the Mirage Studios original with later TMNT #1 issues published by other companies (Archie, IDW). Only the 1984 Mirage issue has significant value.

• The second printing is far more common than the first and is sometimes misrepresented as a first printing in online sales.

Value by Condition

Good (CGC 2.0-3.0): $750 - $2,000 Significant wear, possible spine damage or small tears, maybe writing or stamps. Even in rough shape, the first printing's tiny print run supports four-figure prices.

Fine (CGC 5.0-6.0): $3,000 - $7,000 Moderate wear, minor spine stress, light cover soiling. The comic is complete with all pages, but it's clearly been read and stored imperfectly.

Very Fine (CGC 7.0-8.0): $8,000 - $25,000 Minor wear on corners and spine. Cover retains gloss. Pages are clean. A CGC 8.0 represents a well-preserved copy, likely stored in a bag and board relatively early in its life.

Near Mint (CGC 9.0-9.4): $30,000 - $75,000 Nearly perfect. Minimal handling evidence. Sharp corners, flat spine, white pages. These copies were likely bagged and boarded shortly after purchase.

Near Mint/Mint (CGC 9.6-9.8): $100,000 - $245,000 A CGC 9.8 sold for $245,000 at ComicConnect in September 2021. In 2016, a CGC 9.6 sold for $55,000 at Heritage Auctions. The jump between 9.4 and 9.8 is dramatic because so few copies survive in this condition from a 3,000-copy print run of a comic nobody initially thought was worth preserving.

Price trend: Values have cooled slightly from the 2021 peak but remain strong. The nostalgia factor (40th anniversary in 2024) and the enduring cultural impact of the franchise keep demand steady.

Known Errors and Variations

The first printing has no recognized error variants. However, there are signed copies that carry a premium:

• Signed by Eastman and Laird: Both signatures add significant value. A CGC Signature Series copy with both creators' autographs can command 20-50% above an unsigned copy of the same grade.

• Eastman-only signature: More common (Eastman does more convention appearances), carries a modest premium.

The comic's value is almost entirely about the printing. First printing, full stop.

Authentication & Fakes

Fakes and misrepresented copies are a real concern. The most common scam isn't outright counterfeiting but passing off second printings as first printings. Since the only difference between printings is a small notation on the interior, sellers sometimes claim ignorance.

What to verify:

• Inside front cover should have NO printing notation for a first printing

• Paper stock on first printings is slightly different in texture from later printings

• The cover ink on first printings tends to be slightly different in saturation

Professional grading is essential for any copy you're buying or selling for more than a few hundred dollars. CGC is the standard for comic books. Current grading fees range from $50 for economy service (value under $400) to $150+ for modern tier (value $400-$3,000), and significantly more for express or walk-through service on high-value books. For copies worth $10,000+, expect grading fees of $150-$300 depending on turnaround.

Where to Sell

Best venues:

• Heritage Auctions: The largest comic book auction house. They handle TMNT #1 first printings regularly and have the buyer base for six-figure copies.

• ComicConnect / ComicLink: Both specialize in high-end comics and have sold record copies of this issue.

• eBay: Suitable for lower-grade copies (CGC 5.0 and below), but be prepared for fees of approximately 13% plus payment processing.

• Local comic shops: May buy ungraded copies but will pay 40-60% of retail value.

Expected selling costs:

• CGC grading: $50 - $300+ depending on declared value and turnaround

• Auction house buyer's premium: 19.5-20% (paid by buyer)

• Seller's commission: 0-10% at major auction houses for high-value books

• Insured shipping: $30 - $150+ depending on declared value

Not sure if you have a first printing? Upload a photo of the inside front cover to Curio Comp for a quick check.

Related Items