2016 Pokemon XY Evolutions Charizard Holo #11 (PSA 10 Population)

The Charizard holographic from the 2016 XY Evolutions set occupies a fascinating position in the Pokemon trading card market. It is simultaneously one of the most accessible and most debated Charizard cards in the hobby. A direct homage to the original 1999 Base Set Charizard, card number 11/108 in XY Evolutions was designed to trigger nostalgia in collectors who grew up opening Base Set packs in the late 1990s. And it worked. The card has become one of the most actively traded Pokemon cards in the modern era, with PSA 10 (Gem Mint) copies generating particular interest among investors and collectors tracking population numbers.

The XY Evolutions Set: A Nostalgia Play

Released on November 2, 2016, the XY Evolutions expansion was the twelfth and final set in the Pokemon XY series. The set was explicitly designed as a celebration of the original 1999 Base Set, featuring updated artwork and mechanics for many of the same Pokemon that appeared in the game's inaugural English release.

The set contained 108 cards (113 including secret rares) and immediately resonated with collectors and players alike. For longtime fans, it was a chance to experience the magic of opening Base Set packs again, but with modern card quality and printing standards. For newer collectors, it provided an affordable entry point into Charizard collecting without the five-figure price tags attached to original Base Set holos.

Production numbers for XY Evolutions were substantial. The set was printed in enormous quantities, and unlike many other Pokemon expansions, it continued to see print runs well into 2021 due to sustained demand driven by the pandemic-era Pokemon collecting boom. This extended availability has important implications for both present supply and long-term value.

The Charizard Holo #11: Card Details

The Charizard holo (card number 11/108) is a Stage 2 Fire-type Pokemon with 150 HP. It features two attacks: Energy Burn (which converts all Energy attached to Charizard into Fire Energy) and Fire Spin (200 damage, requiring the discard of 3 Energy). The artwork is a deliberate callback to the original Base Set Charizard illustration by Mitsuhiro Arita, rendered with the updated design language of the XY era.

The holo pattern covers the card's artwork area with a sparkle effect, though it lacks the deeper, more dramatic holo patterns found on some premium modern cards. The card is classified as Holo Rare within the set, making it one of the more difficult pulls from a standard booster pack, but far from the rarest card in the expansion.

PSA 10 Population: The Key Discussion

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) is the dominant grading authority in the Pokemon card market, and the PSA 10 Gem Mint grade is the highest standard grade a card can receive. For the XY Evolutions Charizard #11, the PSA 10 population is a critical factor in understanding the card's value.

As of recent population reports, approximately 2% of all submitted XY Evolutions Charizards have received the coveted PSA 10 grade. That percentage sounds low, but the sheer volume of submissions means the absolute number of PSA 10 copies is substantial, likely numbering in the thousands. New PSA 10 copies continue to be added to the population at a rate of roughly 10 to 20 per month as collectors continue to submit raw cards for grading.

This ongoing population growth is a double-edged sword for investors. On one hand, it suggests strong collector engagement and sustained interest. On the other hand, a growing supply of PSA 10 copies can put downward pressure on prices, particularly during periods of softening demand.

Understanding the Grading Scale

For collectors new to graded Pokemon cards, here is a quick overview of the key PSA grades and what they mean for this card:

PSA 10 (Gem Mint): The card must be virtually perfect, with sharp corners, perfect centering (within a small tolerance), no surface marks, clean edges, and a flawless holo surface. This is the grade that commands the highest premium.

PSA 9 (Mint): A nearly perfect card with one minor flaw, often slightly off-center or with a barely perceptible edge imperfection. PSA 9 copies trade for a significant discount to PSA 10.

PSA 8 (Near Mint to Mint): A card showing minor wear that is visible upon close inspection. Very slight edge whitening or a minor surface blemish might be present.

PSA 7 and below: Visible wear that progressively increases with lower grades. Cards at these grades still have value but are significantly discounted from higher grades.

Current Market Values

The XY Evolutions Charizard Holo #11 is one of the most actively traded Pokemon cards, providing robust pricing data across all conditions. Here is the current market picture:

Grade / Condition	Description	Price Range
PSA 10 (Gem Mint)	Perfect grade, slabbed	$350 - $500
PSA 9 (Mint)	Near-perfect, slabbed	$100 - $150
PSA 8 (NM-MT)	Minor flaw, slabbed	$60 - $90
PSA 7 or Below	Visible wear, slabbed	$30 - $60
Raw Near Mint	Ungraded, excellent condition	$60 - $85
Raw Lightly Played	Ungraded, minor edge wear	$40 - $60
Raw Moderately Played	Ungraded, visible wear	$25 - $45
Raw Heavily Played	Ungraded, significant wear	$15 - $30

Recent eBay sold listings show raw Near Mint copies trading in the $60 to $85 range, with PSA 10 copies fluctuating between $350 and $500 depending on market conditions and auction dynamics. TCGPlayer listings for raw Near Mint copies hover around $66 to $85.

It is worth noting that prices for this card have fluctuated considerably over the past few years. During the peak of the 2020-2021 Pokemon market boom, PSA 10 copies briefly traded above $500. The market correction that followed brought prices down, and they have since stabilized at current levels.

The Bull and Bear Cases

Collectors and investors debate the long-term trajectory of this card regularly. Here are the key arguments on both sides:

The bull case: The XY Evolutions Charizard is a nostalgia anchor for an entire generation of Pokemon fans. As the original Base Set Charizard becomes increasingly unaffordable (PSA 10 copies sell for $50,000 to $400,000+), the Evolutions version serves as the accessible alternative. The card benefits from the Charizard premium, the most consistently valuable Pokemon across all sets and eras. Long-term demand from millennial collectors is likely to strengthen as that generation enters peak earning years.

The bear case: The massive print run means supply is enormous. The PSA 10 population continues to grow, diluting scarcity. Modern printing quality means a high percentage of raw copies can potentially achieve PSA 9 or 10 grades, unlike vintage cards where high grades are genuinely rare. The card may have already peaked during the 2021 bubble.

Collecting Tips

If you are looking to acquire this card, consider the following:

For collectors who want the card for personal enjoyment, buying a clean raw copy in the $60 to $80 range offers excellent value. The card looks fantastic in a toploader or magnetic case and you avoid the premium associated with professional grading.

For investors targeting PSA 10 copies, be patient and watch the market. Prices fluctuate regularly, and deals can be found during periods of lower overall market activity. Consider purchasing from sellers on eBay or PWCC who offer best-offer listings, where you can often negotiate below the asking price.

If you are considering submitting raw copies for grading, examine the card carefully under strong lighting before spending the $20 to $30 PSA grading fee. Check centering (front and back), corners (use magnification), edges (look for whitening), and the holo surface (check for scratches or print lines). Only submit cards that appear flawless to the naked eye, as the PSA 10 hit rate for this card is roughly 2%.

The 2016 XY Evolutions Charizard Holo #11 may not have the historical gravitas of its 1999 Base Set ancestor, but it has earned its own place in the Pokemon collecting universe. Whether it appreciates or depreciates from current levels, it remains a beautiful card that captures the magic of Charizard, the most beloved Pokemon of them all.

Browse all Trading Cards →

Related Items