1952 Topps #407 Eddie Mathews Rookie

The 1952 Topps set is the foundation of modern baseball card collecting, and card #407 Eddie Mathews is one of its crown jewels. As the last card in one of the most storied sets ever produced, the Mathews rookie occupies a unique position: it is both a key card of a Hall of Fame slugger and a high-number card from a series that was famously dumped into the Atlantic Ocean by Topps when unsold inventory became a storage problem. That combination of player significance, set importance, and dramatic backstory makes the 1952 Topps Mathews one of the most coveted cards in the entire hobby.

The 1952 Topps Set

The 1952 Topps baseball card set was not the company's first (that was the 1951 Red Back and Blue Back sets), but it was the set that established the template for modern baseball cards. At 2-5/8 by 3-3/4 inches, the cards were larger than anything that had come before. The design featured color photographs (actually colorized black-and-white images) with bold borders, team logos, and a card back loaded with statistics and biographical information.

The set was issued in multiple series throughout the 1952 season. The high-number series (cards #311 through #407) was released last and distributed primarily in limited geographic areas. This restricted distribution, combined with Topps's infamous decision to dump unsold cases of high-number cards into the ocean, means that high-number 1952 Topps cards survive in much smaller quantities than low-number cards.

Card #407, Eddie Mathews, is literally the last card in the set. In an era when many collectors organized their cards numerically, the last card in a set often suffered the most handling (placed at the back of a stack, repeatedly shuffled past). This additional handling, combined with the already-low survival rate of high numbers, makes well-preserved Mathews cards genuinely scarce.

The Player

Edwin Lee Mathews Jr. (1931 to 2001) was one of the most prolific power hitters of the 1950s and 1960s. Playing primarily for the Braves (in both Boston and Milwaukee), Mathews hit 512 career home runs and was a nine-time All-Star. He was part of the legendary 1957 Milwaukee Braves team that won the World Series, alongside Hank Aaron and Warren Spahn.

Mathews was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1978. His career overlapped with and complemented Hank Aaron's, and together they formed one of the most productive home run duos in baseball history.

At the time of his 1952 Topps card, Mathews was a 20-year-old rookie with the Boston Braves. He would hit 25 home runs in his rookie season, a promising debut that merely hinted at the power to come. By 1953, he hit 47 home runs, establishing himself as one of the premier sluggers in the National League.

Condition Grades

Value and Price Guide

For context within the 1952 Topps set:

The Mathews is the second most valuable card in the set after Mantle, a testament to both his Hall of Fame career and the unique circumstances of the #407 card.

The Ocean Dump Story

One of the most famous stories in card collecting lore involves Topps's decision to dispose of unsold inventory of 1952 high-number cards. According to multiple accounts (including from Topps executive Sy Berger himself), cases of unsold high-number cards were loaded onto barges and dumped into the Atlantic Ocean off the New Jersey coast.

The reasons were practical: by 1953, the 1952 cards were unsellable inventory taking up valuable warehouse space. Topps was a business, not a preservation society, and no one in 1953 anticipated that baseball cards would become serious collectibles.

The dump created artificial scarcity in the high-number series, dramatically reducing the available supply of cards #311 through #407. This scarcity, combined with the presence of Mickey Mantle's card (#311) and the Mathews rookie (#407) in the high-number series, has made 1952 Topps high numbers among the most valuable post-war baseball cards in existence.

Authentication and Identification

Card dimensions. 1952 Topps cards measure approximately 2-5/8 by 3-3/4 inches, larger than modern standard cards. Any significant deviation suggests trimming or a reprint.

Card stock. Authentic 1952 Topps cards have a specific card stock with a grayish core visible at the edge. The front has a glossy finish, and the back has a matte texture with a specific gray tone.

Color and printing. The colorization process used in 1952 gives the photographs a distinctive look that is difficult to replicate. Under magnification, the printing should show period-correct halftone dot patterns.

Back design. The card back features Mathews's statistics, biographical information, and a small "baseball tips" section. The red and blue ink on the back should match known authentic examples.

Centering. 1952 Topps cards frequently have poor centering. Well-centered examples are uncommon and command substantial premiums.

Reprints and counterfeits. Topps itself has issued reprints of the 1952 set for anniversary editions. These are clearly marked as reprints on the back. Counterfeits also exist and can be sophisticated. Third-party grading (PSA, SGC, BGS) is essential for authentication at these values.

Investment Perspective

The 1952 Topps Mathews has been a strong performer in the card market over the long term. Its value is supported by multiple factors: Hall of Fame player, last card in the most important modern set, high-number scarcity, and the ocean dump legend. These fundamentals make it one of the more stable "blue chip" cards in the hobby.

The card benefits from being more accessible than the 1952 Topps Mantle while sharing much of the same provenance story. For collectors who cannot justify a seven-figure Mantle purchase, the Mathews offers an entry into the 1952 Topps high-number market at a fraction of the cost.

Browse all Sports Cards →

Related Items