1911 T205 Gold Border Christy Mathewson Value and Price Guide

Christy Mathewson smiled from his T205 Gold Border card like a man who had nothing to prove. By 1911, he had already won 300 games, thrown three shutouts in a single World Series, and earned a reputation as the most respected player in baseball. The card shows him in a relaxed pose, the gold border gleaming around his portrait. It would become one of the most sought-after tobacco cards in the hobby.

Fourteen years later, Mathewson was dead at 45, his lungs destroyed by poison gas he accidentally inhaled during a World War I training exercise. The card outlived the man and became a memorial of sorts, a reminder of baseball's first true gentleman star. PSA 1 examples sell for $500 to $800. A PSA 5 (EX) commands $5,000 to $15,000. Higher grades are exceptionally rare.

Quick Value Summary

• Item: 1911 T205 Gold Border Christy Mathewson

• Year: 1911

• Category: Sports Cards (Baseball, Pre-War Tobacco)

• Condition Range:

  • PSA 1 (Poor): $400 - $800
  • PSA 2 (Good): $700 - $1,200
  • PSA 3 (VG): $1,200 - $2,500
  • PSA 4 (VG-EX): $2,500 - $5,000
  • PSA 5 (EX): $5,000 - $10,000
  • PSA 6 (EX-MT): $8,000 - $15,000
  • PSA 7+ (NM): $15,000 - $30,000+

• Total Auction Sales (PSA): Over $526,000 across 268 recorded auction sales

• Rarity: Scarce in any grade. Very rare above PSA 5.

The Story

Christopher Mathewson pitched for the New York Giants from 1900 to 1916. He won 373 games, a National League record that still stands. His signature pitch, the "fadeaway" (what we now call a screwball), baffled hitters for over a decade. In the 1905 World Series, he threw three complete-game shutouts in six days, allowing just 14 hits total. Nobody has matched that performance in over a century.

But Mathewson's fame extended beyond statistics. He was a college-educated man in an era when most ballplayers were rough laborers. He did not drink, did not gamble, and reportedly refused to play on Sundays. Newspapers portrayed him as the ideal American athlete. Parents held him up as a role model. He was, in many ways, the first baseball player to be famous for his character as much as his talent.

In 1918, Mathewson enlisted in the Army and was assigned to the Chemical Warfare Division in France. During a training exercise, he was accidentally exposed to mustard gas. The exposure damaged his lungs permanently. He developed tuberculosis and spent years in a sanitarium in Saranac Lake, New York. He died on October 7, 1925, during the World Series, a coincidence that seemed almost literary.

The T205 Gold Border set was produced by the American Tobacco Company in 1911 as insert cards in cigarette packs. The set contains 208 cards, each featuring a player portrait surrounded by a distinctive gold-foil border. The gold borders give the cards their name and their beauty, but they also make high-grade examples extremely difficult to find. The foil chipped, flaked, and wore away with handling.

How to Identify It

Card features:

• Front: Color lithograph portrait of Mathewson with a warm expression, wearing a baseball cap

• Border: Distinctive gold-foil border (the defining characteristic of the T205 set)

• Back: Advertisements for various American Tobacco Company brands (Hassan, Honest Long Cut, Cycle, Sovereign, etc.). The back brand can affect value slightly.

• Size: Approximately 1.5" x 2.6" (standard tobacco card size)

• No card number: T205 cards are not numbered. They are identified by player name.

Back variations: Multiple tobacco brands appear on T205 backs. The Mathewson card is known with several back variants:

• Hassan

• Honest Long Cut

• Cycle

• Sovereign

• Others

Back brand generally does not dramatically affect value for Mathewson's card, though certain backs may carry slight premiums among advanced collectors.

Common confusions:

• T206 Christy Mathewson: The more famous T206 "White Border" set (1909-1911) also includes Mathewson cards. T206 cards have white borders, not gold. Different set, different catalog numbers.

• 1911 Turkey Red Mathewson: A larger cabinet-style card from the same era. Different format and set entirely.

Value by Condition

PSA 1 Poor ($400 - $800): Heavy creasing, staining, or paper loss. The card is identified as Mathewson but shows significant damage. Gold border may be largely missing. Even at this grade, the card sells because of Mathewson's stature and the card's age.

PSA 2 Good ($700 - $1,200): Major wear but structurally intact. Creases present. Gold border shows heavy wear and chipping. Corners are rounded. Image is clear enough to identify.

PSA 3 VG ($1,200 - $2,500): Moderate wear. Some gold border remaining. Corners show rounding. Light creasing acceptable. Color remains reasonably vibrant. This is where many collectors enter the pre-war tobacco card market.

PSA 4 VG-EX ($2,500 - $5,000): Light to moderate wear. Gold border shows wear but is largely present. Minor corner issues. No heavy creasing. Attractive card for display.

PSA 5 EX ($5,000 - $10,000): Light wear. Gold border is mostly intact with minor edge wear. Corners show slight rounding. Clean surface. This is a strong collector-grade example.

PSA 6 EX-MT ($8,000 - $15,000): Minimal wear. Gold border is well-preserved. Corners are close to sharp. Surface is clean and vibrant. Very scarce at this grade.

PSA 7 NM+ ($15,000 - $30,000+): Near-perfect. Gold border is essentially complete and bright. Sharp corners. No creases or stains. Exceptional examples in this range are trophy cards. Very few exist.

Authentication and Fakes

Pre-war tobacco cards are frequently counterfeited and altered.

Common issues:

• Trimming: Cutting the edges to create sharper corners or remove damage. Trimmed cards receive an "Authentic" label from PSA/SGC without a numerical grade.

• Re-colored borders: The gold foil border can be touched up or repainted. Under magnification, re-coloring shows different texture and reflectivity.

• Complete counterfeits: Modern reproductions printed on period-appropriate paper. These can be sophisticated. The printing dot pattern under magnification is the best way to spot them.

• Rebacks: The front of one card married to the back of another. Check that the paper grain, thickness, and aging are consistent between front and back.

Professional grading is essential for any pre-war tobacco card. PSA, SGC, and Beckett (BVG) all grade tobacco cards. SGC is particularly respected in the pre-war market.

Grading costs:

• PSA Regular: $50 per card

• SGC Standard: $30-$40 per card

• For high-value submissions (declared value over $2,500): fees increase proportionally

Where to Sell

Best venues:

• Heritage Auctions: Pre-war baseball cards are a Heritage specialty. Their sports card auctions routinely set records.

• Robert Edward Auctions (REA): Specializes in pre-war sports memorabilia. Excellent for tobacco cards.

• eBay: Suitable for graded examples in all price ranges. Use auction format for cards over $500.

• PWCC Marketplace: Major sports card auction platform with strong pre-war demand.

Tips:

• SGC holders are often preferred by pre-war card collectors. Consider SGC grading if your card is raw.

• The back brand should be noted in any listing (serious collectors care).

• A PSA 5 or better Mathewson T205 is a blue-chip collectible. Take your time and sell through the right venue.

Not sure about the condition of yours? Upload a photo to Curio Comp for an estimate in seconds.

Explore More

Browse all Sports Cards →

Related Items