All-American Comics #16 (1940, First Green Lantern)

All-American Comics #16 (1940): The Origin of Green Lantern and One of Comics' Greatest KeysThere are comic books, and then there are key issues -- the comics where something happened for the first time that changed the trajectory of an entire medium. All-American Comics #16, published by DC Comics (then National Allied Publications) with a cover date of July 1940, belongs in the highest tier of key issues. It contains the origin and first appearance of the Green Lantern, the original version of the character named Alan Scott who would become one of the foundational heroes of the Golden Age. This single issue established a character, a mythology, and a power ring concept that has generated billions of dollars in entertainment across comics, television, film, and merchandise for over eighty years.### The Context: The Golden Age of ComicsAmerican comic books entered their first great creative and commercial explosion in the late 1930s. Superman debuted in Action Comics #1 in June 1938, Batman followed in Detective Comics #27 in 1939, and by 1940 both National Allied Publications (which would become DC Comics) and other publishers were working to build out rosters of costumed heroes to capitalize on the format's extraordinary popularity with young readers.The economic context matters: comic books sold for ten cents and were produced cheaply, but they sold in enormous quantities. A popular title could move hundreds of thousands of copies per issue. The industry was building essentially from nothing, with creators who were largely making up the rules of superhero fiction as they went. The character types, origin story conventions, and visual language of superhero comics were all being invented simultaneously in a competitive publishing environment.All-American Comics was an anthology title, meaning it contained multiple stories featuring different characters per issue. The Green Lantern story was one feature among several in issue #16, but it was the one that captured readers' imaginations and launched into its own title.### The Creation: Martin Nodell and Bill FingerGreen Lantern was created by Martin Nodell and writer Bill Finger. Martin Nodell, who later used the pen name Mart Dellon on the early issues, reportedly conceived the character on a New York City subway platform after seeing the green light on a signal lantern. The image of a man with the power of a magical lantern and a ring that could create anything he imagined became the conceptual kernel of the Green Lantern.Bill Finger, whose contributions to DC Comics are extensively documented (he was also instrumental in developing Batman's character, history, and mythology, receiving credit for this only posthumously), helped craft the origin story and dialogue for the character. Finger's involvement meant the Green Lantern origin had a narrative sophistication that distinguished it from simpler superhero origins of the period.The character they created -- Alan Scott, a railroad engineer who discovers the mystical Green Lantern crafted from a meteor fragment and learns that its power ring can create anything the wearer wills -- drew on mythological tradition and pulp fiction in roughly equal measure. The green flame, the ring, the vulnerability to wood, the oath: all of these elements appeared in the original issue and established the template that later Green Lanterns would be measured against.### The Story in Issue #16The Green Lantern origin story in All-American Comics #16 tells of Alan Scott, an engineer who survives a bridge collapse that was sabotaged by a rival. Among the wreckage, he discovers a strange lantern carved from a meteor. The lantern speaks to him, explaining its history -- the meteor fell to earth centuries earlier and its green flame granted life to a man in ancient China, then madness to a man in medieval times, and now would grant a hero power to Alan Scott.Alan fashions a ring from the lantern's metal and charges it with the green flame, gaining the ability to project the ring's power against anything except wood. The original design for his costume -- red tunic, green lantern symbol, purple cloak -- reflected the pulp illustration style of the era and was vibrant enough to stand out on a newsstand crowded with competing comics.The story established all the key elements: the power, the limitation (vulnerability to wood rather than yellow, which came later with Hal Jordan), the origin of the magical lantern, and the character's determination to use his power for justice. For a ten-cent anthology story in 1940, it was remarkably coherent world-building.### How Rare Is This Issue?All-American Comics #16 is genuinely scarce. Published in 1940, it was printed as disposable periodical entertainment for children, not as a collectible. Comics were read, traded, shared, and discarded. The paper drives of World War II destroyed an enormous percentage of comics published before and during the war years. Normal household use, storage in humid spaces, and eighty-plus years of attrition have reduced the surviving population to a small fraction of the original print run.The CGC (Certified Guaranty Company) census for All-American Comics #16 shows an extraordinarily small number of graded copies:- Only a handful of copies have been graded at any quality level- The highest-graded known copy is a CGC 9.4 (Near Mint)- A copy graded CGC 6.5 (Fine+) sold at Heritage Auctions in 2018 for $215,100- The CGC 9.4 copy has reportedly received an offer of approximately $1,000,000- Copies in low grades (2.0 to 4.0) sell in the $30,000 to $80,000 rangeThese figures place All-American Comics #16 in the top tier of Golden Age comic book values alongside Action Comics #1, Detective Comics #27, Marvel Comics #1, and a small number of other first-appearance issues from the 1938 to 1942 period.### Value at a Glance| CGC Grade | Estimated Value ||---|---|| 1.0 (Fair) | $20,000 - $35,000 || 2.0 (Good) | $35,000 - $60,000 || 3.0 (Good/VG) | $55,000 - $85,000 || 4.0 (Very Good) | $80,000 - $120,000 || 5.0 (Very Fine-) | $110,000 - $160,000 || 6.0 (Fine) | $150,000 - $220,000 || 6.5 (Fine+) | $215,000+ (2018 Heritage sale) || 8.0 (Very Fine) | $400,000 - $600,000 (est.) || 9.4 (Near Mint) | $1,000,000+ (est., offer on record) |These are estimates informed by known sales and the general market trajectory for top Golden Age keys. The thin market -- very few copies sell publicly in any given year -- means individual sale results can vary significantly.### Identifying the IssueAll-American Comics #16 has a distinctive Sheldon Moldoff cover depicting the Green Lantern in his original red and green costume, with the green lantern itself prominently featured. Key identification points:Cover date and issue number: "July 1940" and the number 16 appear on the cover. The indicia inside the issue contains publishing information confirming the National Allied Publications (DC) origin.Green Lantern lead story: The issue's main feature is "The Green Lantern" origin story. This should be present and complete in any copy being considered.Page count and content: Golden Age comics like this had specific page counts and included other stories, features, and advertisements from the period. A complete copy will have all pages intact.Physical characteristics: Paper, ink, and binding characteristics consistent with 1940 printing. The newsprint paper yellows and brittles with age; restored copies may show paper whitening or other signs of conservation treatment.### The Restoration QuestionFor Golden Age comics at this value level, the question of restoration is critically important. Restoration refers to any process used to improve the appearance or stability of a comic beyond its current natural condition -- cleaning, pressing, adding paper, trimming edges, restoring color, etc.CGC identifies restoration in its grading notes. A "restored" copy of All-American Comics #16 trades at a substantial discount to an unrestored copy of the same apparent grade. Buyers at this level work exclusively with reputable dealers and major auction houses (Heritage Auctions, ComicConnect, ComicLink) who have the expertise and CGC certification infrastructure to ensure accurate representation of restoration status.An unrestored CGC copy with official grade documentation is the standard for any serious high-value Golden Age transaction. Raw (ungraded) copies of this issue are extremely unusual at this point -- virtually any surviving example will have been submitted for grading given the value.### Alan Scott vs. Hal Jordan: The Two Green LanternsA collector note worth understanding: the Green Lantern that most contemporary audiences know from modern comics, animation, and film is primarily Hal Jordan, introduced in Showcase #22 in 1959. Hal Jordan was reimagined as a science-fiction test pilot who receives his power ring from a dying alien, part of an intergalactic Green Lantern Corps.Alan Scott, the original Green Lantern from All-American Comics #16, operates from a completely different mythology -- the magical lantern, no alien origin, the vulnerability to wood rather than yellow. He remained a separate character in DC's continuity, eventually classified as being on a parallel Earth (Earth-2) when the Silver Age continuity was established. Modern DC has integrated the two traditions in various ways, but Alan Scott's first appearance predates and exists independently of the Hal Jordan version.For collectors, this means All-American Comics #16 is specifically the origin of Alan Scott/the original Green Lantern, and its value is tied to that specific historical claim. It is a Golden Age key, not a Silver Age key.### The World War II Paper Drive FactorOne reason Golden Age comics are so genuinely rare today is the wartime paper drives of 1942 to 1945. The US government actively encouraged citizens to donate paper products for the war effort, and comic books -- lightweight, expendable, viewed as children's entertainment -- were among the most commonly donated items. Estimates suggest that anywhere from 60% to 80% of comics published before and during the war years were destroyed through these drives, household attrition, and general lack of preservation awareness.This is not speculation or collector mythology -- it is documented history. The paper drives were organized community events, and comics were listed explicitly among the desired items. Children who collected comics were encouraged to donate their collections. Libraries and institutions that might otherwise have preserved periodicals donated their stock.The result is that a print run that might have been several hundred thousand copies for a popular title in 1940 has been reduced to dozens of surviving examples eighty years later. The surviving population of All-American Comics #16, whatever it was, has been compressed by this history into the small number of CGC-documented copies that exist today.Understanding this history reframes the scarcity. These books are not rare because they were expensive or limited at original publication -- they were mass-market ten-cent periodicals. They are rare because they survived against all probability through decades of ordinary household life, attrition, and a wartime culture that actively encouraged their destruction.### The Role of CGC in the MarketThe Certified Guaranty Company transformed the Golden Age comic market when it began operations in 2000. Before CGC, buying a high-value Golden Age comic required trusting the seller's condition description and your own assessment skills. Restoration was a constant concern and extremely difficult to detect without expert examination. The market was characterized by uncertainty that discouraged large transactions.CGC introduced a standardized grading scale, restoration detection methodology, and tamper-evident encapsulation that brought transparency to a previously opaque market. Today, virtually every serious high-value Golden Age transaction involves CGC-graded copies. The CGC census for any given issue provides the most accurate available picture of surviving populations and grade distribution.For All-American Comics #16, the CGC census is the definitive record of known surviving copies. A complete census study of this issue would show every graded copy, its grade, and whether it is marked as restored or unrestored. This transparency is essential at the value levels this book commands.### The Broader Market for Golden Age KeysAll-American Comics #16 sits in a market category where demand consistently outstrips supply. The number of serious collectors who specifically target first appearances of major DC and Marvel characters from the Golden Age has grown substantially, partly driven by the billion-dollar film and television properties derived from these characters.Heritage Auctions handles the majority of high-grade Golden Age key sales in the United States and consistently reports strong results. The combination of genuine scarcity, cultural significance, and the tangibility of owning a physical piece of comics history continues to drive this market. All-American Comics #16 is one of the most significant first appearances in the entire Golden Age, and its market position reflects that.Browse all Comic Books →

Related Items