1875-CC Twenty-Cent Piece

The twenty-cent piece is one of American numismatics' most interesting failures. It existed for only four years (1875-1878), was produced in only a few denominations, and was largely hated by the public who constantly confused it with the similarly-sized quarter dollar. But that brief, failed existence has made the complete series highly collectible, and the 1875-CC is the first-year Carson City issue, making it one of the more desirable dates in the set.

Why the Twenty-Cent Piece Existed

Congress authorized the twenty-cent piece in March 1875, responding to a practical problem: in the western United States, the smallest silver coin available was the quarter, and many small transactions required exact change that the quarter could not provide. The ten-cent piece helped but did not fully address the gap. A twenty-cent coin would theoretically fill that space.

The problem was immediately obvious in practice: the twenty-cent piece was nearly identical in size to the quarter. While the two coins had different designs (the twenty-cent piece used a seated Liberty obverse, and importantly had a plain edge versus the quarter's reeded edge), most people handling change in poor light or by touch could not reliably distinguish them. Complaints were immediate and widespread.

By 1876, only proof coins were struck at Philadelphia. By 1878, the denomination was officially abolished. The twenty-cent piece had existed for exactly four years and had served no useful purpose.

The Carson City Issue

The first year of production, 1875, included issues from three mints: Philadelphia, Carson City, and San Francisco. The Carson City issue (CC mintmark) had a mintage of 133,290, making it the highest-mintage of all Carson City twenty-cent pieces. The 1876-CC, with a mintage of only 10,000, is dramatically rarer.

For a complete set of business-strike twenty-cent pieces, collectors need four coins: 1875, 1875-CC, 1875-S, and 1876-CC. The 1875-CC occupies the middle range of difficulty, more common than the 1876-CC but more interesting to many collectors than the Philadelphia 1875 due to the western mint association.

Design Details

The twenty-cent piece was designed by William Barber, the Chief Engraver of the Mint. The obverse shows the familiar Seated Liberty figure holding a shield with the inscription "LIBERTY," surrounded by stars and the date. The reverse shows an eagle and is similar in style to contemporary silver coinage.

The distinguishing feature from the quarter is the plain (smooth) edge. The quarter's reeded edge was specifically maintained to ensure the two coins were distinguishable by touch. In theory. In practice, most people did not notice or bother.

Condition Grades and Values

Certified examples from PCGS or NGC are the standard for any coin valued over $100. The 1875-CC is not heavily counterfeited, but altered 1876-CC coins (adding a CC mintmark to a common 1875) are theoretically possible, making certification prudent for any coin in AU or better grades.

The Collecting Argument

For a collector focused on complete sets of short-lived US coin series, the twenty-cent piece is one of the most manageable: only four business-strike dates, all of which can be found in circulated grades for reasonable prices, with the key date (1876-CC) being the main challenge. The 1875-CC is a satisfying piece for any US coin collection, representing a monetary experiment that failed quickly and completely.

The short production run and the story of public rejection add narrative interest that most coins lack. Holding an 1875-CC is holding a coin that virtually everyone who used it disliked, which is a certain kind of historical poignancy.

Browse all Coins →

Related Items