1958 Topps #47 Roger Maris Rookie Card: The Complete Collector's Guide

Roger Maris broke Babe Ruth's single-season home run record in 1961, hitting 61 home runs in a feat so controversial that commissioner Ford Frick initially insisted on a separate record with an asterisk if Maris didn't accomplish it in 154 games (he didn't). That asterisk controversy, which followed Maris for decades, has paradoxically made him one of the most compelling figures in baseball history. And his 1958 Topps rookie card (#47) is the physical object that connects collectors to the beginning of that story.

About the Card

The 1958 Topps baseball set features a distinctive design: player photos against yellow or white backgrounds with name panels at the bottom. Card #47 pictures a young Roger Maris in his Cleveland Indians uniform (he was traded to Kansas City later in 1958 and then to the Yankees in late 1959).

This is actually a two-player card, paired with Bob Martyn, both identified as "Outfield" for their respective teams. The multi-player rookie card format was standard for Topps in this era.

Key Details:

• Set: 1958 Topps Baseball

• Card Number: #47

• Players: Roger Maris / Bob Martyn

• Maris's Team at time of issue: Cleveland Indians

• Design Era: Late 1950s Topps

Why This Card Matters

Roger Maris's career statistics might look modest compared to sluggers of other eras, but context matters enormously:

• 61 home runs in 1961: Broke Babe Ruth's 1927 record of 60, a mark that had stood for 34 years

• 1960 AL MVP (hitting .283 with 39 HRs)

• 1961 AL MVP (the 61-HR season)

• Back-to-back AL MVP awards in a Yankees dynasty era

• World Series appearances: 7 times with the Yankees and Cardinals, winning in 1961, 1962, and 1964

The asterisk controversy, the media pressure Maris endured in 1961, and the eventual removal of the asterisk from the record books in 1991 (by commissioner Fay Vincent) have all cemented Maris as one of baseball's most dramatically human figures. The 1998 Home Run Chase between Sosa and McGwire brought renewed attention to Maris's record and its significance, which had a lasting positive effect on his card market.

Condition Challenges for 1958 Topps

The 1958 Topps set presents specific challenges:

Card Stock: 1958 Topps cards are thinner and more prone to bending and creasing than later sets. Handling damage is extremely common.

Yellow Backgrounds: Cards with yellow areas (which many 1958 Topps cards have) show toning and staining more readily than darker backgrounds.

Print Quality: Soft focus and color misregistration are period-typical issues.

Centering: Off-center cuts are common throughout the set.

Back Printing: The back printing on 1958 Topps is particularly susceptible to staining from improper storage.

Current Market Values

Grade	Approximate Value
Poor/Good (raw, played)	$30 - $100
VG (raw)	$150 - $350
NM (raw)	$500 - $1,200
PSA 4 (VG-EX)	$150 - $350
PSA 5 (EX)	$300 - $700
PSA 6 (EX-MT)	$600 - $1,500
PSA 7 (NM)	$1,500 - $4,000
PSA 8 (NM-MT)	$5,000 - $12,000
PSA 9 (MINT)	$20,000 - $50,000
PSA 10 (GEM MT)	Extremely rare

PSA population data shows that high-grade examples are genuinely scarce. The thin card stock and storage conditions cards experienced over 60+ years mean that truly gem-quality copies are exceptional finds.

Maris in Context: The 1961 Season

To understand the sustained demand for this card, it's worth understanding what 1961 meant. Maris's pursuit of Ruth's record was one of the most heavily scrutinized events in sports history:

• He and teammate Mickey Mantle both pursued Ruth's record simultaneously, with the media framing it as a competition (Mantle was the fan favorite, which added to the pressure on Maris)

• The asterisk controversy created a cloud over the achievement that lasted until 1991

• Maris lost clumps of hair during the season from stress-related alopecia, a detail that humanized his story

• He ended the season hitting his 61st homer on the final day of the season in a half-empty stadium, as the controversy had exhausted public goodwill

This story is now viewed with deep sympathy rather than skepticism, and that cultural rehabilitation has supported the card's long-term collector demand.

Comparing to Other 1950s Outfielder Rookies

Card	PSA 7 Approx. Value
1958 Topps Maris #47	$1,500 - $4,000
1955 Topps Sandy Koufax #123	$6,000 - $15,000
1957 Topps Frank Robinson #35	$1,000 - $3,000
1957 Topps Brooks Robinson #328	$2,000 - $5,000

Maris trades at values that reflect his specific historical significance: lower than Koufax due to shorter career length and career statistics, but premium over most contemporaries due to the record and the dramatic narrative around it.

What to Look For When Buying

Multi-Player Card Considerations: Both players must be presentable on a multi-player card. Maris is typically the more visually prominent of the two, but a card where one player's portion has been defaced or heavily marked will suffer.

Centering Both Ways: Check vertical AND horizontal centering. The 1958 Topps set had problems both ways.

Back Staining: Flip the card over and examine the back under good light. Tan or brown staining is very common and often not fully visible in photos.

Creases: Run your finger lightly along the card surface while examining under raking light. Subtle creases that don't show in photography are a frequent issue.

The Investment Case

The Maris rookie benefits from what might be called the "asterisk dividend": the decades of controversy ultimately made the card more interesting and more culturally loaded than a straightforward record-setter's card might have been. Collectors who appreciate baseball history find the Maris story compelling in a way that purely statistical careers sometimes aren't.

Long-term, the card's value is supported by the genuine scarcity of high-grade examples and the durable interest in New York Yankees memorabilia specifically.

Final Thoughts

The 1958 Topps Roger Maris rookie card is one of those pieces that carries more weight than its raw statistics suggest. The combination of a singular achievement (61 home runs), a dramatic human story (the pressure, the asterisk, the rehabilitation), and genuine card scarcity in high grade makes this an essential holding for any serious vintage baseball card collection. Few cards from the 1950s can match the narrative richness Maris brings to the hobby.

Browse all Sports Cards →

Related Items