Amazing Spider-Man #252 (1984, First Black Costume)

Before there was Venom, there was a simple wardrobe change that shocked comic book readers. Amazing Spider-Man #252, published in May 1984, marks the first appearance of Spider-Man wearing the black alien symbiote costume in his own title. While the actual origin of the costume was told in Marvel Super Heroes Secret Wars #8 (published months later but set chronologically earlier), ASM #252 is where most readers first encountered the new look. The sleek, all-black design with the distinctive white spider symbol remains one of the most recognizable costume changes in superhero history.

This issue is a cornerstone of any Spider-Man key issue collection and a critical precursor to the entire Venom mythology that would explode four years later in ASM #300.

The Story Behind the Issue

The black costume originated in a fan submission. Randy Schueller, a comic reader from Illinois, sent Marvel a letter in 1982 suggesting that Spider-Man get a new black costume. Marvel purchased the idea for $220. The concept evolved through multiple creative hands before becoming the alien symbiote storyline that defined Spider-Man's 1980s era.

ASM #252 was written by Tom DeFalco with pencils by Ron Frenz and inks by Brett Breeding. The story picks up after the events of Secret Wars, with Spider-Man returning to Earth in his new black costume. The issue's cover by Ron Frenz is striking: Spider-Man swings toward the reader in the all-black suit, with the classic costume reflected in a building window behind him.

The timing was significant. Secret Wars #8, which actually showed Spider-Man acquiring the alien costume on Battleworld, would not be published until December 1984. This means readers of ASM #252 in May encountered the costume change before they knew its origin, creating a mystery that drove readership and speculation for months.

What Makes It Collectible

First black costume appearance: This is the first time most readers saw Spider-Man's new look. While the chronological origin came in Secret Wars #8, ASM #252 holds the "first appearance in own title" distinction that many collectors prioritize.

Venom connection: The black costume is the alien symbiote that would eventually bond with Eddie Brock to become Venom. ASM #252 is the beginning of the Venom origin story.

Costume significance: The black costume represents one of the most important visual changes in superhero history. It influenced Spider-Man stories for decades and spawned multiple characters (Venom, Carnage, Anti-Venom, and more).

Cover appeal: The Frenz cover is visually compelling and immediately recognizable. Strong cover art is a significant driver of comic collectibility.

Copper Age key: As a major key from the early Copper Age, ASM #252 benefits from strong collector interest in this increasingly appreciated era.

Variant Awareness

ASM #252 exists in both direct edition (Spider-Man head in UPC area) and newsstand edition (standard barcode). The newsstand edition is scarcer and commands a modest premium in high grades.

A Canadian price variant also exists with a 75-cent cover price instead of the US 60 cents. Canadian price variants from this era are increasingly recognized as scarce and collectible.

Condition Grading Guide

Grade	Description	Key Factors
9.8 (NM/MT)	Near perfect	White pages, perfect spine
9.6 (NM+)	Outstanding	Minor imperfections only
9.4 (NM)	Near Mint	Minor wear, tight
9.0 (VF/NM)	Excellent	Minor wear, great appeal
8.0 (VF)	Very Fine	Light wear, slight creasing
6.0 (FN)	Fine	Moderate wear
4.0 (VG)	Very Good	Noticeable wear

Specific Concerns

Black cover: The predominantly black cover shows every flaw. White rub, fingerprints, and spine stress are all highly visible against the dark background. This makes high-grade copies scarcer than the print run would suggest.

Spine ticks: The thin cover stock of 1984 Marvel comics is prone to spine ticks (small stress marks along the spine). Multiple spine ticks can drop a grade significantly.

Manufacturing quality: Print registration and ink coverage vary across the print run. Some copies show superior cover ink density, which enhances eye appeal.

Market Values

Grade	Direct Edition	Newsstand
9.8 (NM/MT)	$1,200-1,800	$1,800-2,800
9.6 (NM+)	$500-750	$700-1,100
9.4 (NM)	$250-400	$350-550
9.2 (NM-)	$150-250	$225-350
9.0 (VF/NM)	$100-175	$150-250
8.0 (VF)	$60-100	$80-140
6.0 (FN)	$30-55	$40-70
4.0 (VG)	$15-30	$25-40

ASM #252 values track closely with ASM #300 values, as both are part of the symbiote/Venom storyline. Venom film releases and related media boost demand for both issues simultaneously.

Authentication Tips

• Verify correct interior ads for the May 1984 publication date

• Check for original staples (replacement staples indicate restoration)

• Examine the cover ink under magnification for consistent dot pattern printing

• Verify page count and centerfold attachment

• Look for evidence of pressing, cleaning, or color touch restoration

Storage and Preservation

• Use acid-free current-size bags and boards

• Store upright in climate-controlled conditions

• Replace bags every 3-5 years

• Handle by edges only with clean hands

• Consider CGC encapsulation for grades 8.0 and above

The Bottom Line

Amazing Spider-Man #252 is an essential Spider-Man key that represents the beginning of one of the most important storylines in Marvel history. The black costume debut set in motion events that would create Venom, Carnage, and an entire symbiote mythology that continues to generate new stories and billion-dollar films.

With readable copies available for under $30 and investment-grade copies accessible in the hundreds, ASM #252 offers strong value across the collecting spectrum. Its connection to both Spider-Man's visual history and the Venom franchise ensures long-term collector interest.

Browse all Comic Books →

Related Items