1927-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: America's Rarest 20th Century Gold Coin

If you are building a list of the most important American coins ever struck, the 1927-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle belongs near the top. Despite a recorded mintage of 180,000 coins, only approximately 12 to 15 examples are known to exist today. The rest were melted. The circumstances of that melting, the Great Depression, the gold recall of 1933, and decades of subsequent destruction, created one of the most extraordinary rarities in American numismatics.

Except for the famously problematic 1933 Double Eagle (of which only one example can be privately owned under current law), the 1927-D is the crown jewel of twentieth-century United States gold coinage.

Background: The Saint-Gaudens Design

The Double Eagle ($20 gold piece) underwent a famous redesign at the insistence of President Theodore Roosevelt, who found the existing coins artistically inadequate compared to ancient Greek coinage. He commissioned sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens to create something worthy of the republic.

Saint-Gaudens delivered. The design features Liberty striding forward with a torch and olive branch, the sun rising behind her, with the Capitol Building in the background. On the reverse, a flying eagle above the rising sun. It is widely considered the most beautiful coin ever produced by the United States Mint.

Saint-Gaudens died in 1907 before seeing his design enter production, but the coins struck from 1907 through 1933 bear his legacy. The design ran in high-relief and modified-relief versions; by 1927 the production version was the modified (lower) relief that allowed higher-speed production.

The Denver Mint and the 1927-D

The Denver Mint struck 180,000 Double Eagles dated 1927 with the D mintmark. This was a substantial production run, suggesting these coins should be available in quantity today.

They are not.

The coins were struck and held in the mint's vaults, never released into circulation. The onset of the Great Depression eliminated the commercial need for gold coin in circulation. By 1933, when President Franklin Roosevelt issued Executive Order 6102 requiring Americans to turn in gold coins, bullion, and gold certificates, the unreleased 1927-D coins were still sitting in Denver's vaults.

They were not distributed. They were eventually melted.

Exactly how a small number escaped this fate is not entirely documented. Some likely left the mint through legitimate channels in the years before the recall. Some may have been secreted out by individuals aware of their coming fate. The precise provenance of each surviving example is a subject of numismatic research.

The Known Examples

Approximately 12 to 15 examples of the 1927-D Double Eagle are known to exist, with most held in private collections or major institutional numismatic collections. The coins have appeared at major auctions several times over the decades, each appearance generating significant collector attention and record prices.

The authentication of any claimed 1927-D is a serious undertaking. Given the scarcity and value, PCGS and NGC grading certifications are essentially mandatory for establishing authenticity. Both services maintain population reports that track graded examples.

The Denver Mint production included no major die varieties that have been documented for the known survivors, but each example has been studied individually for its specific characteristics.

Specifications

Specification	Detail
Denomination	$20 (Double Eagle)
Mintmark	D (Denver)
Year	1927
Composition	90% gold, 10% copper
Weight	33.436 grams
Diameter	34mm
Designer	Augustus Saint-Gaudens
Edge	Lettered (E PLURIBUS UNUM, stars)
Mintage	180,000 (virtually all melted)
Known surviving	Approximately 12-15

What These Coins Are Worth

Because only a handful of examples exist, standard condition-based price guides are not particularly useful. The 1927-D trades as a trophy piece where the mere existence of a genuine example commands extraordinary premiums.

Known auction results have placed individual examples in the range of $1 million to $5 million depending on condition and the competitive dynamics of a given sale. MS63 or above graded examples have sold for $3 million to over $5 million. Circulated or lower-grade examples (if such exist) would still command seven-figure sums given the absolute rarity.

Legal Considerations

One aspect of 1927-D ownership that any buyer must verify: the legal status of pre-1933 gold coins.

Unlike the 1933 Double Eagle, which is subject to government ownership claims (only one specimen was monetized and sold with government permission in 2002), pre-1933 gold coins including the 1927-D are legal to own by American citizens. The government's gold recall of 1933 applied to gold coins in circulation. Coins that were held outside the United States or that left the country through legitimate means before the recall are considered legally held private property.

Verifying the provenance chain for a 1927-D is not just a good practice but a legal necessity for any serious buyer. Reputable auction houses handling these coins will have conducted full provenance research.

Investment Considerations

The 1927-D is not a coin you buy for investment diversification. It is an absolute rarity in a category where price is determined by the intersection of a small number of motivated buyers and near-zero supply. Historical prices have moved dramatically upward since the coin was first recognized as a major rarity in the mid-twentieth century.

Holding costs (insurance, storage, PCGS/NGC holder maintenance) are a consideration at these values. Most examples reside in bank vaults or with major institutions between sale appearances.

The Broader Saint-Gaudens Market

For collectors who want exposure to the Saint-Gaudens design without a multi-million dollar entry point, the Philadelphia Mint 1927 Double Eagle (no mintmark) is plentiful in MS64 and lower grades. Common date Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles from Philadelphia in MS63-64 trade in the $2,500 to $5,000 range, while MS65 examples bring $4,000 to $8,000.

The design itself remains widely available. It is the Denver mintmark and the extraordinary fate of those 180,000 coins that makes the 1927-D so extraordinary.

Browse all Coins →

Related Items