1909-S Indian Head Cent (No VDB): The Key to the End of an Era

The 1909-S Indian Head cent occupies a dual distinction in numismatic history: it is the final year of the Indian Head cent series (which ran from 1859 to 1909) and one of the lowest-mintage dates in the entire series. Understanding why this coin is so significant requires understanding both its production context and what came immediately after it.

The Indian Head Cent Series

The Indian Head cent was designed by Chief Engraver James Barton Longacre and introduced in 1859. Despite the name, the portrait on the obverse is not a Native American but rather a representation of Liberty wearing a Native American headdress. The design was used continuously from 1859 through 1909.

By 1909, the cent was due for a redesign. The Lincoln cent, designed by Victor D. Brenner, was introduced to commemorate the centennial of Abraham Lincoln's birth. The Indian Head cent was retired.

The 1909-S Production Context

The "S" mint mark indicates production at the San Francisco Mint. The 1909-S Indian Head cent had a mintage of only 309,000 coins, the second-lowest in the series (only the 1877 is scarcer at 852,000 originally struck, with survival rates affecting which is harder to find).

This low mintage reflects winding-down production as the Lincoln cent introduction was imminent. San Francisco produced a final small batch of Indian Head cents while the transition to Lincoln cents was being prepared.

The "No VDB" Distinction

When the Lincoln cent was introduced in 1909, designer Victor D. Brenner included his initials "VDB" prominently on the reverse. Public controversy over the prominence of the initials led to their removal almost immediately. This created three key 1909 cent varieties:

• 1909 VDB (Philadelphia): Very common but desired as the first Lincoln cent

• 1909-S VDB (San Francisco): Rare and highly valuable (3,031 minted)

• 1909 Indian Head: Late Philadelphia production of the old design

• 1909-S Indian Head (No VDB): San Francisco production of the Indian Head cent before the Lincoln cent; the subject of this guide

The "No VDB" designation simply means this is an Indian Head cent, distinct from the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent.

Condition Grades and Value

Color designations (RD=Red, RB=Red-Brown, BN=Brown) significantly affect values for uncirculated examples. Original red copper color (RD) commands the highest premiums.

What to Look for in High-Grade Examples

Full strike: The Indian Head cent design can be weakly struck in areas like Liberty's feathers and the "AMERICA" lettering. Full, well-struck examples are preferred.

Surface quality: Marks, bag marks, and contact marks from storage with other coins reduce grade. The highest-grade examples have minimally marked surfaces.

Eye appeal: The overall visual impression of color, strike, and surfaces contributes to "eye appeal" which can affect values beyond strict technical grade.

The 1909-S in Context

Completing an Indian Head cent set requires acquiring the 1909-S as the penultimate or final acquisition (along with the 1877). Both are genuine numismatic challenges: the 1877 has a lower mintage but both require significant budget and patience to find in good grade.

For collectors interested in the transition between series, owning both a 1909-S Indian Head cent and a 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent (if budget permits) tells the complete story of that numismatic moment in 1909 when one era ended and another began.

Browse all Coins ->

Related Items