1804 Quarter Eagle (13-Star Reverse)

In the rarefied world of early American gold coinage, the 1804 Quarter Eagle with 13 stars on the reverse stands as one of the most elusive prizes a collector can pursue. With perhaps five or fewer confirmed surviving examples, this variety is a coin that most numismatists will only ever see in auction catalogs. It represents the earliest period of American gold coinage, when the young United States Mint was still experimenting with designs, denominations, and production techniques.

Historical Context

The United States Mint began producing gold coins in 1795, starting with half eagles ($5) and eagles ($10). The quarter eagle ($2.50 denomination) was authorized by the Coinage Act of 1792 but did not enter production until 1796. These early quarter eagles were small, beautiful coins that reflected the new nation's aspiration to stand alongside the great European monetary powers.

The early quarter eagle design features the "Capped Bust Right" or "Turban Head" type, designed by Robert Scot, the Mint's chief engraver. The obverse depicts Liberty facing right, wearing a cap or turban (interpretations vary), surrounded by stars. The reverse shows a heraldic eagle with a shield on its breast, holding an olive branch and arrows.

The 13-Star vs. 14-Star Reverse

The 1804 quarter eagle exists in two varieties, distinguished by the number of stars on the reverse. The 14-star reverse is the more common variety (though still quite scarce), while the 13-star reverse is genuinely rare.

The difference relates to the political reality of statehood. As new states were admitted to the Union, the Mint added stars to the reverse design of various coins to represent the growing number of states. By 1804, there were 17 states, but the Mint used different star counts on different dies, sometimes reflecting earlier die states or different engraver decisions.

The 13-star reverse represents the original colonies and is believed to have been produced from an earlier die or a die created with the original colony count. The 14-star reverse is the more standard variety for the 1804 production. Exactly why two different reverse dies with different star counts were used in the same year remains a topic of numismatic debate.

Mintage and Survival

The total mintage of 1804 quarter eagles (both varieties combined) is recorded as 3,327 coins. However, this figure is somewhat misleading. Mint records from this era are imprecise, and some coins recorded as "1804" may have been struck with dies bearing earlier dates, a common practice at the early Mint.

Of the total mintage, the 13-star reverse variety is believed to account for a small fraction. Ed Price, a noted researcher of early quarter eagles, documented the rarity of this variety through decades of correspondence with other specialists. The number of confirmed surviving 13-star examples is estimated at approximately five, making this one of the rarest varieties in all of American numismatics.

For perspective, many famous collectors never managed to acquire one. Neither the Eliasberg Collection (considered the most complete US coin collection ever assembled) nor the Garrett Collection contained an 1804 13-star quarter eagle. This is a coin that transcends "scarce" and enters the realm of "legendary."

Condition Grades

The Sheldon scale is the standard for grading US coins:

Grade	Description
MS-65 and above	Gem Mint State, full luster, minimal contact marks (no known 1804 13-star QE exists in this grade)
MS-60 to MS-64	Mint State with varying levels of contact marks and luster (extremely unlikely for this variety)
AU-50 to AU-58	About Uncirculated, slight wear on highest points, substantial remaining luster
EF-40 to EF-45	Extremely Fine, light overall wear with all major details sharp
VF-20 to VF-35	Very Fine, moderate wear with major features clearly defined
F-12 to F-15	Fine, even moderate wear, all lettering and major design elements visible
VG-8 to VG-10	Very Good, well-worn but major design elements remain
G-4 to G-6	Good, heavily worn, outline of design visible, date legible

The finest known 1804 13-star quarter eagle is graded AU-50 by PCGS (the Pittman specimen). Most surviving examples are in circulated grades, reflecting over two centuries of existence.

Value and Price Guide

Given the extreme rarity, actual sales data is sparse. Values are estimated based on the few transactions that have occurred:

Grade	Approximate Value Range
AU-50 (finest known)	$150,000 to $300,000+
EF-40 to EF-45	$100,000 to $200,000
VF-20 to VF-35	$75,000 to $150,000
F-12 to F-15	$50,000 to $100,000
VG-8 to G-4	$30,000 to $60,000

For comparison, the more common 14-star reverse variety:

Grade	Approximate Value Range
MS-63 to MS-65	$30,000 to $80,000
AU-50 to AU-58	$10,000 to $25,000
EF-40 to EF-45	$7,000 to $12,000
VF-20 to VF-35	$5,000 to $8,000
F-12 and below	$3,000 to $6,000

The Pittman specimen (PCGS AU-50) last sold for $94,000 over a decade ago. Given the general appreciation of rare US gold coins since then, a current market value well above $150,000 would be expected if it were to appear at auction today.

Authentication and Identification

Star count. The defining feature is the number of stars on the reverse. Count them carefully, as some coins are weakly struck and stars can be difficult to distinguish. The 13-star variety has 13 six-pointed stars arranged around the eagle. The 14-star variety has 14.

Die characteristics. Each die has unique characteristics visible under magnification, including die cracks, die polish lines, and specific placement of design elements. Reference works on early quarter eagles document the known die varieties in detail.

Weight and composition. The 1804 quarter eagle should weigh approximately 4.37 grams and be composed of .9167 fine gold (22 karat). Weight testing is a basic authenticity check, though it is not conclusive by itself.

Edge. The coin has a reeded edge. The reeding pattern should be consistent with known authentic examples.

PCGS and NGC certification. For a coin of this rarity and value, third-party grading and authentication by PCGS or NGC is essential. Both services have extensive reference collections and expert staff who specialize in early US gold coins. A certified example provides the highest level of confidence.

Provenance. With so few surviving examples, provenance is particularly important. Each known specimen has a documented ownership history that can be traced through major collections and auction appearances. A coin claiming to be an 1804 13-star quarter eagle without a credible provenance chain should be treated with extreme skepticism.

Counterfeits. Sophisticated counterfeits of rare early US gold coins exist. Cast counterfeits can be detected by examining edge details and surface characteristics. Die-struck counterfeits are harder to identify but can be detected through die analysis and metallurgical testing. Only buy from established numismatic dealers or through major auction houses with guarantee policies.

The Broader Capped Bust Right Series

The 1804 13-star quarter eagle is part of the Capped Bust Right (or Turban Head) series, which runs from 1796 to 1807. This short series includes several other rare dates and varieties:

The 1796 "No Stars" variety (the first US quarter eagle, with no stars on the obverse) is one of the most valuable US coins of any denomination. The 1797 and 1798 quarter eagles are scarce. The 1805 and 1806 are more available (by early gold standards) and serve as the primary collecting entry point for the series. The 1807 is the last year of the type before the design was changed.

Collectors who pursue the complete Capped Bust Right series face one of the greatest challenges in American numismatics. The 1804 13-star reverse is arguably the most difficult variety to acquire in the entire series, and completing a set without it is considered a remarkable achievement in itself.

Collecting Philosophy

For the vast majority of collectors, the 1804 13-star quarter eagle will remain an aspirational piece, something to admire in museum exhibits and auction catalogs. And there is nothing wrong with that. The coin's rarity is part of what makes it compelling. It reminds us that early American coinage was produced in small quantities by a young Mint working with limited resources, and that the survival of any individual coin across 220 years is itself a minor miracle.

For those with the means and determination to pursue one, the 1804 13-star quarter eagle represents the summit of early American gold coin collecting. It is rare, historically significant, beautiful in its archaic design, and connected to a pivotal moment in American monetary history. There are very few numismatic prizes that can match it.

Browse all Coins →

Related Items